WRIR 03-4262


You can DOWNLOAD THIS REPORT (9,721 KB) in Portable Document Format (PDF)

You can DOWNLOAD PLATE 1 OF THIS REPORT (22,953,531 KB) in Portable Document Format (PDF)

You can DOWNLOAD PLATE 2 OF THIS REPORT (22,552,911 KB) in Portable Document Format (PDF)
The Adobe PDF Reader program is available for free from Adobe.


Shoemaker, W. Barclay and Edwards, K. Michelle, 2003, Potential for Saltwater Intrusion into the Lower Tamiami Aquifer near Bonita Springs, Southwestern Florida: U.S. Geological Survey Water-Resources Investigations Report 03-4262, 74 p.

ABSTRACT:

A study was conducted to examine the potential for saltwater intrusion into the lower Tamiami aquifer beneath Bonita Springs in southwestern Florida. Field data were collected, and constant- and variable-density ground-water flow simulations were performed that: (1) spatially quantified modern and seasonal stresses, (2) identified potential mechanisms of saltwater intrusion, and (3) estimated the potential extent of saltwater intrusion for the area of concern.

MODFLOW and the inverse modeling routine UCODE were used to spatially quantify modern and seasonal stresses by calibrating a constant-density ground-water flow model to field data collected in 1996. The model was calibrated by assuming hydraulic conductivity parameters were accurate and by estimating unmonitored ground-water pumpage and potential evapotranspiration with UCODE. Uncertainty in these estimated parameters was quantified with 95-percent confidence intervals. These confidence intervals indicate more uncertainty (or less reliability) in the estimates of unmonitored ground-water pumpage than estimates of pan-evaporation multipliers, because of the nature and distribution of observations used during calibration. Comparison of simulated water levels, streamflows, and net recharge with field data suggests the model is a good representation of field conditions.

Potential mechanisms of saltwater intrusion into the lower Tamiami aquifer include: (1) lateral inland movement of the freshwater-saltwater interface from the southwestern coast of Florida; (2) upward leakage from deeper saline water-bearing zones through natural upwelling and upconing, both of which could occur as diffuse upward flow through semiconfining layers, conduit flow through karst features, or pipe flow through leaky artesian wells; (3) downward leakage of saltwater from surface-water channels; and (4) movement of unflushed pockets of relict seawater. Of the many potential mechanisms of saltwater intrusion, field data and variable-density ground-water flow simulations suggest that upconing is of utmost concern, and lateral encroachment is of second-most concern. This interpretation is uncertain, however, because the predominance of saltwater intrusion through leaky artesian wells with connection to deeper, more saline, and higher pressure aquifers was difficult to establish.

Effective management of ground-water resources in southwestern Florida requires an understanding of the potential extent of saltwater intrusion in the lower Tamiami aquifer near Bonita Springs. Variable-density, ground-water flow simulations suggest that when saltwater is at dynamic equilibrium with 1996 seasonal stresses, the extent of saltwater intrusion is about 100 square kilometers areally and 70,000 hectare-meters volumetrically. The volumetric extent of saltwater intrusion was most sensitive to changes in recharge, ground-water pumpage, sea level, salinity of the Gulf of Mexico, and the potentiometric surface of the sandstone aquifer, respectively.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Abstract
Introduction

Purpose and Scope
Description of Study Area
Previous Studies
Acknowledgments
Hydrogeology of Southwestern Florida
Lithology and Stratigraphy
Hydrogeologic Units and Hydraulic Characteristics
Water Budget
Water Quality and Geochemistry
Ground-Water Flow and Mechanisms of Saltwater Intrusion
Lateral Encroachment
Upward Leakage
Downward Leakage
Relict Seawater
Simulation of Saltwater Intrusion near Bonita Springs
Modeling Approach
Code Selection
Constant-Density Ground-Water Flow Simulator
Variable-Density Ground-Water Flow Simulator
Spatial Discretization and Assignment of Aquifer Properties
Simulation of Predevelopment Conditions
Boundary Conditions
Recharge
Rivers
No Flow
Constant Heads and Concentrations
Simulation Results
Model Calibration to Typical, Modern, and Seasonal Stresses
Boundary Conditions
No Flow
Constant Heads
Rivers
General Heads
Recharge
Wells
Parameter Estimation
Confidence Intervals
Potential Movement of Saltwater to Equilibrium with Typical, Modern, and Seasonal Stresses
Baseline Scenario
Mechanisms of Saltwater Intrusion
Extent of Saltwater Intrusion
Sensitivity Analyses
Mechanisms of Saltwater Intrusion
Extent of Saltwater Intrusion
Model Limitations
Summary
Selected References
Appendix: Monitoring Stations Used for this Study